Traning and Education

[Translate to Danish:] text

[Translate to Danish:]

Testing & Certification - FAQ

What types of equipment can be certified?
  • Both open and closed equipment used in food processing environments can be certified. EHEDG maintains a list of all equipment that has been certified.

  • Although there are no limitations on the complexity of the piece of equipment, typically only small, individual components are certified rather than large, complex machines or processing systems.

  • For certification of open equipment, ALL equipment surfaces are evaluated as product contact surfaces and must meet all hygienic design criteria in relevant EHEDG guidelines.

  • Currently, only closed equipment with pipe connections between 25 mm (1 in) O.D. and 75 mm (3 in) O.D. can be tested due to limitations of CIP testing.
How are different sizes of the same piece of equipment evaluated for certification?

In general, all sizes of the same piece of equipment must be evaluated with a design review and CIP tested prior to certification. However, in a few instances where equipment designs are considered completely scalable by an EHEDG Authorized Test Institute, testing of only one size can be used for certification of the entire range. In most instances, equipment is NOT completely scalable. Currently, the only alternative to testing each size is to perform computational fluid dynamics modelling (CFD) of the different designs to select the size for testing that may be the most difficult to clean based on wall shear stresses and fluid exchange in critical areas. If this characteristic size passes CIP testing, the sizes with higher wall shear stresses and fluid exchange in critical areas may also be considered for certification and listed on the same certificate.

Why does some equipment require CIP testing for certification?

All closed pieces of equipment which are installed in a pipeline, e.g. pumps, valves, and inline sensors, must be tested according to the method of EHEDG Doc. 2. This test is a screening test for hygienic design and identifies areas that may contain a crevice which can trap soil and microorganisms or are not easily cleaned due to the flow dynamics.

Why some equipment does not require CIP testing for certification?

Closed equipment which fully comply with the hygienic design requirements can be certified without testing. Examples are pipe lines or pressure sensors without elastomeric seals.

What is cleanability testing, CIP testing, and Doc. 2 testing?

These terms are interchangeable and refer to "a method of assessing the in-place cleanability of food processing equipment" described in EHEDG Document 2 published by EHEDG. The test method is used as a basic screening test for hygienic design. It is used to determine if areas (or features) within a piece of equipment are “easily cleanable” by comparing the test results to that of a standard reference pipe soiled and cleaned during the same test. Due to inherent variability in the cleaning of equipment, the test must be repeated successfully at least 3 times for equipment to be eligible for certification. This test is required for equipment to be certified as Type EL Class I and EL Aseptic Class I.

What are the differences between EL Class I, EL Class I AUX, and EL Class II certifications?

EL Class I is only for closed equipment, intended to be cleaned-in-place (CIP) with liquids, and can be CIP tested using the method of Doc. 2. EL Class I AUX is for certification of auxiliary open equipment which is intended to be cleaned-in-place with liquids but not tested. EL Class II is for equipment which is intended to be cleaned with liquids but must be disassembled or dismantled prior to cleaning.

Is there a test for cleanability of open equipment?

No. Since open equipment cannot currently be tested to ensure cleanability, open equipment intended to be cleaned with liquids can only be certified as EL Class I AUX or EL Class II. Open equipment intended to be dry cleaned only can be certified as ED Class I or Class II.

Why do EHEDG Certificates require Annual Prolongation and 5-year Renewal?
  • The annual prolongation process provides EHEDG assurance by the certificate holder that the equipment design has not been changed in the past year.

  • The 5-year renewal process allows EHEDG to ensure that certified equipment meets the latest criteria for certification due to changes in the EHEDG guidelines, certification criteria, or test procedures. This process is established in 2015.
Why are the seal or elastomeric materials listed on the certificate?

Different elastomers may have different material properties. Experience has shown that different materials in the same mechanical design may affect the equipment cleanability. Since 2009 the certificate lists the elastomers that were CIP tested. The equipment is only certified when used with the elastomers listed on the certificate. Each elastomer listed on the certificate must be CIP tested using the method of Doc. 2.

Can the same piece of equipment hold two different certificates?

Yes. For example Type EL Class I for cleanability and Type EL Aseptic Class I for sterile applications.

Can the same piece of equipment be certified under different names and sold by different companies (reseller-agreement)?

Yes, individual certification files will be issued. The evaluation report of the certificate will refer to the original equipment (test report or evaluation report).

What must be done with the existing certificate if the name of the company changes or the name of the equipment is changed?

The original Certification Institute issues a new certification file with the new name on it as a Revision. If the existing certificate is older than 5 years, the certification will go into the 5-year renewal process.

What parts of "closed" equipment are evaluated and certified by EHEDG?

For closed equipment components intended to be cleaned in-place (CIP) with liquids (EL CLASS I certified), only the internal, wetted surfaces/parts are evaluated and certified to meet the hygienic design criteria according to EHEDG guidelines. This means that for pumps, valves and in-line sensors; the motor, drive, actuator or frame (if present) are NOT evaluated and certified for cleanability according to EHEDG guidelines. Only the internal, product contact surfaces are evaluated and certified according to EHEDG guidelines and, if necessary, tested for easy cleanability according to Doc. 2.

What is the significance of the Month and Year on the EHEDG Certified Logo?

The date on the EHEDG certificate and Certified Logo indicate the month and year that the equipment was last reviewed and certified. As new guidelines have been created, existing ones updated and test methods improved, more recently certified equipment has to meet more detailed guideline criteria and/or pass more specific testing criteria. Equipment with certificates issued prior to 2009 were only reviewed according to EHEDG Doc. 8 while more recently issued certificates now take into account all EHEDG documents relevant to that piece of equipment. Equipment holding certificates with the most recent dates must meet the latest EHEDG guideline criteria and test methods. For the reasons described above, beginning in 2015, all certificates will be required to be renewed every 5 years to ensure the equipment meets the latest guideline and test method criteria.

Can multiple items of equipment be listed on one Certificate?

If the multiple items are categorized according to the same Certification Class, e.g. TYPE EL CLASS I, and the designs are similar and covered by the same group of applicable EHEDG Guidelines then they can be listed on the same Certificate provided that they are certified in the same Month and Year, see FAQ above. This means that a manufacturer can maintain one Certificate for groups of similar equipment such as electromagnetic flow meters, coriolis flow meters, rotary lobe pumps, centrifugal pumps, diaphragm type sensors, etc. The design evaluation report will include references to all the individual cleanability test reports, if necessary.

Is it possible to have metal to metal joints certified?

EHEDG only allows metal to metal joints for equipment subject to certification under Type EL Class II and Type ED Class I and II. As they may harbor soil or liquids and could corrode, EHEDG does not recommend any direct metal to metal joints other than welding.